Showing posts with label comparison. Show all posts
Showing posts with label comparison. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 3, 2007

The inivitable Dean comparisons

Barack Obama's spectacular second quarter cash has brought out again the old expected comparisons to the Howard Dean campaign.

Like Obama, Dean raised a lot of money online but ultimately lost in the primary. The former governor did keep his movement going and eventually became head of the Democratic National Committee (DNC), a position he still holds today. Howard and his "Deaniacs" are locked in a struggle with the old establishment represented by groups like the Democratic Leadership Council (DLC) over the direction of the Democratic Party.

The Dean-Obama mantra generally has Obama facing the same problems as Dean in expanding beyond his obviously strong netroots support.

Dean's supporters did look something like a cross-section of the internet community, or even just a certain segment of that community. He had problems diversifying his base.

Anyone involved in the Obama campaign knows that this is not the case with the senator's supporters. He base is not perfect. He could do much better, for example, among Latinos and some polls suggest he needs to outreach more to lower income people. However, overall Obama's team looks very much like a cross-section of America.

Obama's success is likely due to many factors. He started off much better-known nationally than Dean. His 2004 Democratic Convention speech and successful senatorial campaign made him the rising star of the Democratic Party and he was presented as such repeatedly by the national media. Two of his books have become best-sellers and he managed to establish a John F. Kennedy-like following among young people even before he announced his candidacy.

Because he is the first truly viable African American candidate for president, he naturally has attracted strong support among that important segment of the Democratic voting population. Many of Obama's supporters did not learn about him on the internet.

However one looks at it, Obama looks better positioned now than Dean ever did during his campaign in terms of the breadth of his support. He already has expanded much beyond the netroots and this will help him also with future outreach.

Obama's consulting team might not be the most experienced in terms of nationwide campaigns of this sort, but they have performed admirably up to this point. They also have the advantage of learning from mistakes of the Dean campaign. They started earlier this time around than Dean and that will help a great deal.

The Dean machine didn't really get rolling until the fall before the primary election started and they really had to rush before the distractions of the Christmas season arrived. With Obama, they will probably have raised more than $70 million by September of 2007, and they already have much of their infrastructure positioned in the early states.

Register to Vote


Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Howard Dean comparison

Some bloggers and commentators have compared the Obama candidacy to that of Howard Dean in 2004 suggesting that the senator's campaign might face the same fate.

There are, of course, some valid comparisons. Both opposed the Iraq War, for example. Both were supported by a large number of younger and "activist" types. However, there are a number of reasons to think that things could end very differently this time:

* Although Dean lost he eventually did find himself a place in the party. He became head of the DNC, the head of the Democratic Party. When he first announced he would run everyone thought he didn't have a chance, but the same people who supported him during his presidential run got him through. When Dean ran the establishment people opposed him because they thought he was too far to the left. Now Dean controls much of the establishment, although he still has significant opposition in the party apparatus. However, because of Dean's presence, things will be smoother for progressive candidates like Obama.

* Obama's team has the opportunity to learn from the Dean campaign's mistakes.

* Obama made national headlines during the 2004 convention. He was featured nationally for months before that time. By the time the primary rolls around he will have had more than three years of national coverage. In comparison, Dean was practically unknown nationally a year before his primary election.

* There is of course no reason to think Obama will have a screaming incident like Dean. I'm sure he'll have his share of gaffes, but the Dean thing was a bit unusual even in the world of politics. Just not the right time I guess.

* The opposition to the war is deeper now than during 2004. Many people think the Democratic victories in the Congressional races last time were indications of a growing desire to end the war. People are also tired of traditional politics and traditional politicians.

* Howard Dean was a great speaker and had great views, but I think it is clear that Barack Obama has a rare type of charisma. He has "rock star" appeal.

There are probably some other reasons I'm not thinking of now, but I should also mention that while Dean had bloggers, Obama has both bloggers and social networkers. The latter are the people who drive websites like Facebook and MySpace.

Bloggers are sort of like media and publicity people, while social networkers are person-to-person like canvassers and phone-bankers. There are many more social networkers than bloggers so if you can utilize them properly it certainly will pay off at the ballot box.

Popular Posts